101 articles Comparison

Savers Roundup October 2024: PC Financial is back; EQ Bank’s business account

Water fountain

After holding steady at or near the top of our charts for more than a year, Motive Financial finally blinked on Round 3 of the Bank of Canada interest rate cuts. Motive Financial’s regular savings account and TFSA interest are now at 3.60%, down from 4.10%. This now makes them tied for 4th on savings account comparison chart, behind Neo Financial (at 4.00%), Wealth One Bank of Canada (at 3.75%), Canadian Tire Bank (at 3.70%), and Saven Financial (at 3.70%). If you count rates when you have a direct deposit sent to your account, you also have EQ Bank at 4.00% and Wealthsimple at 3.75%.

Motive Financial did release an offer for new clients, though: 5.75% for the first 120 days in a new savings account. And it even has a refer-a-friend program to sweeten the pot in the short-term. We’ve listed this on our promotions page, along with many other promos offering up to 6.25%.

Rates down but competition up

Saven Financial, seemingly tired of the Ontario-only label, is finally available outside of Ontario, with the exception of Quebec.

The PC Money account (which was created by PC Financial after its original banking division moved under CIBC and rebranded as Simplii Financial) now has a “savings feature” offering 4.25%! We haven’t added it to our comparison chart yet, but if we did, it would be the new leader.

New GIC leaders after MCAN Financial decreases

MCAN Financial is the newest addition to our GIC comparison chart, with, until last week, chart-topping rates. This leaves MAXA Financial and Wealth One Bank of Canada tied for the lead for all terms (from 4.60% for a 1-year GIC to 4.10% for a 5-year GIC).

Just a couple of months ago, we were impressed with Hubert Financial’s 1-year quarterly GIC rate, which had increased to 5.35% (when compounding on the quarterly terms were taken into account). Although its quarterly cashability is still unique, its rate has fallen quickly from the competition. GIC rates available through brokers have also fallen, and are currently not competitive against rates directly available from financial institutions.

Competition for small business accounts too

EQ Bank’s small business account is finally widely available, at least to those who already have a personal account with them. Its basic premise is a no-fee account to cover a business’s day-to-day needs, with a 3.00% interest rate on your balance.

It has some key feature omissions, such as mobile cheque deposits. But we’ll be following along as its feature set develops.

Poll results: Tangerine Bank and Simplii Financial are popular

Last month, we polled readers on whether they have a Tangerine Bank or Simplii Financial account. Out of 634 respondents, over 40% have accounts with both financial institutions! 73% have a Tangerine Bank account (compared to 71% in our previous poll who have an EQ Bank account), and 50% have a Simplii Financial account. Seems like our readers are well banked!

Current cash back offers

Savers Roundup September 2024: Round 3 of rate cuts

Noodle plate

If you weren’t paying attention this summer, you might have missed 3 key interest rate cuts – for 25 basis points each – from the Bank of Canada already, with the latest decrease coming on September 4. This is before the US has made any cuts, although our southern neighbours are widely expected to make a cut on September 18. The Governor of the Bank of Canada stated “If inflation continues to ease broadly in line with our July forecast, it is reasonable to expect further rate cuts”.

Each round of cuts have triggered predictable decreases in savings account interest rates. The top two rates — at Motive Financial and Neo Financial — have yet to budge at 4.10% and 4.00% respectively, but we’ll see how long they can hold out.

If you factor in the rate you get if you have regular direct deposits, EQ Bank’s 4.00% rate would be near the top of the leaderboard. EQ has kept that rate even after decreasing its base savings account and TFSA rates to 2.25% and 2.75%. There has been a good amount of discussion on our forums about its 30 Day Notice Savings Account, but that rate has now dropped from 5.00% to 4.25%.

GIC interest rates continue to fall, with the top non-broker rates we track as follows:

  • 1 year: 4.75%
  • 2 year: 4.60%
  • 3 year: 4.30%
  • 4 year: 4.25%
  • 5 year: 4.25%

Shorter GIC terms first started to offer higher rates (than longer terms) at the beginning of 2023, and that trend continues today.

The upstarts are popular

A whopping 71% of poll respondents last month said they have an EQ Bank account, and 29% have a Wealthsimple account. 78% of respondents have an account with at least one of the two.

Peak promos for savings accounts?

You can get at least 5.00% in a savings account via short-term promotional rates from the likes of DUCA Credit Union, Manulife Bank, Tangerine Bank, and Vancity as listed on our promos page. Simplii Financial remains the headliner with 6.25% for the first 5 months for new customers. In an environment where rates are dropping, will this be the best we get for the foreseeable future?

Student credit cards

Lena M, who shared her journey on choosing a student bank account a couple of months ago, is back with her review on choosing a student credit card. She has broken down her considerations for a first credit card, and narrowed down her options!

Choosing my first credit card: a student’s journey

New student orientation

As a second-year college student, I’m stepping into the world of credit cards for the first time, trying to figure out what features will best support my financial goals. With so many options out there, it’s important for me to choose a card that not only fits my current needs but also helps me build a solid financial foundation for the future. Whether it’s managing day-to-day expenses, staying on top of payments, or even earning a few rewards along the way, I’m learning what to prioritize to make the most of my first credit card experience.

No annual fees

For me, avoiding annual fees is the most important thing. As a student with a tight budget, I should not have to pay any type of fee to have a credit card and I know that most students feel the same way. It’s a minor but important element that helps in my financial management. I remember thinking about a credit card that cost $100 a year, but I quickly realized that this would take unnecessary money out of my budget. I may focus my money on more essential items, like textbooks, food, and saving for future expenses, if I can find a card without this fee.

Of course, I recognize that an annual fee might be worth it if the rewards are substantial and if my spending were high enough to justify the cost. For example, suppose that a credit card has an annual fee of $100 that offers 2% cash back on all purchases. If you spend $10,000 a year on that card, you’d earn $200 in cash back. After deducting the $100 fee, you’d still come out $100 ahead. But right now, I know my spending habits don’t justify the cost. Since I’m not spending enough to fully benefit from those rewards, avoiding the annual fee is the smarter choice for me at this point.

Low interest rates & flexible payment options

My goal is to pay off my balance in full each month. Credit card debt is one of the worst kinds of debt to carry, with the highest interest rates. As a general rule, I don’t want a credit card to change my spending habits; I should not spend more money than I have in my bank account. That said, unexpected circumstances do happen. I look for a credit card with low interest rates because they act as a safeguard in case I ever have to carry a balance. For example, a lower annual percentage rate (APR) guarantees that I won’t be faced with high interest costs in the event of an unexpected emergency. This is essential for handling any short-term financial difficulty without taking on excessive debt. For example, having a card with a lower APR allows me to better handle the cost of an unexpected bill I just received without being overwhelmed by excessive interest.

Being able to conveniently manage my payments is essential given how busy I am with school, work, and life in general. I want a card where I can configure automated payments and get payment reminders. By ensuring that I don’t miss a payment, I will avoid late fees and possible harm to my credit score.

Credit building

Even though I’m still a student, I plan on building a solid credit score, mainly when I consider my future financial goals, such as purchasing a car or renting an apartment. I find credit building tools provided by credit cards to be really beneficial. I search for credit cards that offer monthly credit reports, access to my credit score, and alerts for any alterations to my credit profile. I can keep an eye on my credit situation and learn how my spending patterns affect my credit score. I also appreciate learning resources that provide advice on how to properly handle credit, raise my credit score, and lay a strong financial foundation for the future.

Sign-up bonus & rewards

Although they aren’t the first feature I look for in a credit card, sign-up bonuses are certainly an extra that can have an instant benefit. For example, reaching certain spending goals during the first several months of owning the card may result in a reward. For instance, a card might offer $100 cashback bonus if I spend $1,000 within the first three months. That extra $100 could go a long way in covering essential expenses like textbooks or a portion of my tuition. It’s like getting paid to use the card for purchases I would be making anyway. In addition to cashback, some cards offer sign-up bonuses in the form of travel points or miles, which can be equally valuable if I plan to use them for future trips or vacations. For example, another card I looked at offered 50,000 travel points after a similar spending requirement, which could easily cover a round-trip flight or several hotel stays. While sign-up bonuses aren’t the primary factor in my decision, they certainly add extra value and make it easier to justify regular use, helping to stretch my budget further.

Online interface / mobile app

In today’s fast-paced digital world, having a good mobile app is important when picking a credit card. As a busy student managing classes, work, and everything else, I need to manage my money quickly and easily. A well-designed mobile app that lets me check balances, track spending, and make payments on the go is a must, especially when my schedule is packed.

Another thing I’d really appreciate is instant transaction notifications via SMS or email. These would help me keep an eye on my spending and catch any weird charges right away. Real-time tracking is very helpful, especially when I’m busy and might not notice every transaction as it happens. Plus, having access to detailed spending breakdowns in the app would make it easier for me to see where my money is going and adjust my budget if needed.

Secure login options like face recognition would also be a big plus, giving me peace of mind that my financial info is safe. Overall, having a solid online platform and mobile app isn’t just a nice-to-have — it’s something that would really help me stay on top of my finances and manage my credit card responsibly.

Should I consider debit cards such as EQ Bank and Wealthsimple that give me rewards?

Considering debit cards that offer rewards, like those from EQ Bank and Wealthsimple, is definitely worth it, especially if you’re like me and want to get rewards without dealing with the risks of a credit card. These kinds of debit cards let you earn cashback or points on your everyday spending, just like a credit card would, but without the worry of carrying a balance or paying interest. This is great if you’re sticking to a debit card for most of your purchases but still want to take advantage of rewards.

For example, EQ Bank and Wealthsimple’s debit cards gives you cashback on every purchase, and since it’s linked directly to your account, you only spend what you actually have, which is really helpful for staying on top of your budget. Wealthsimple’s card is cool too because it gives you cashback that can be automatically invested, so you’re starting to build up some savings or investments just by spending normally.

However, keep in mind that using debit cards won’t help you build your credit history. Unlike credit cards, which report your activity to credit bureaus and can help improve your credit score if used responsibly, debit cards don’t affect your credit. So, while you’re earning rewards and managing your money effectively, you won’t be building a credit history, which is important for things like renting an apartment or applying for loans in the future. If building credit is a goal for you, a credit card might be necessary alongside your debit card strategy.

Conclusion

One thing that I’ve noticed while researching about credit cards is that many of them – especially those with the highest rewards and benefits – have income requirements, which can really limit my options as a full-time student with limited income.

So, after weighing all the options and considering what matters most to me as a second-year college student, I narrowed it down to the Rogers Red Mastercard and the Simplii Financial Cash Back Visa Card. They both seem to check most of the boxes I’m looking for. I decided to give the Rogers Red Mastercard a try since I coincidentally use them for my phone plan. It offers a straightforward cash back of 1% but 1.5% when I redeem against my phone bill. But… my application was denied! Off I went to the Simplii Financial Cash Back Visa card, which offers: 4% back on restaurant purchases; 1.5% back on gas, grocery, and drugstore purchases, as well as pre-authorized payments; and 0.5% of all other purchases. I was approved for my first credit card! I’ll be keeping track of how it goes, so stay tuned for another article where I’ll share my firsthand experience!

Savers Roundup August 2024: Free chequing gets better; rate cut spurs… rate increase?

Two red chairs looking out on a Canadian field

Healthy competition is making hybrid bank accounts better

Motive Financial, with its chart-topping 4.10% Savvy Savings Account and pending takeover by National Bank, has announced some chequing-like changes to its savings account:

  • Unlimited transactions
  • Free Interac e-Transfers
  • No ATM fees from Motive Financial (although you might still get charged a fee by the ATM provider)

Motive Financial’s website no longer mentions its separate chequing account. This means it now offers a single, hybrid bank account that combines the convenience of a chequing account with the higher interest rate of a savings account.

If this sounds familiar, it might be because of the likes of EQ Bank and Wealthsimple, who recently improved their hybrid accounts as well.

EQ Bank’s interest rate of 4.00% if you configure direct deposit now matches Wealthsimple and no longer expires after 12 months. And Wealthsimple now reimburses fees by the ATM provider, matching a feature that EQ Bank pioneered.

Is a student account relevant for a university student?

Second-year university student Lena M has written an article reviewing her banking needs, and determined that none of her best options are labelled as student accounts. With the number of decent “standard” accounts out there, why bother with a student account that you’ll have to change after a few years? Her requirements include unlimited free transactions, a debit card, the ability to open multiple accounts, free ATM access, a good savings account interest rate, and more. That’s similar to the needs of many adults, student or not!

Lena then followed up with a comparison of bank account features which includes EQ Bank, Neo Financial, Simplii Financial, Tangerine Bank, and Wealthsimple.

Another rate cut but a surprising rate increase

The Bank of Canada made a second key interest rate drop in 2.5 months on July 24, spurring another round of corresponding decreases in savings account and GIC interest rates. Zoom out and we’re only back to where interest rates were at in May 2023, which was a high last seen 17 years ago.

We did a double take, though, when we saw Simplii Financial’s latest new customer promo, which actually got better. It now sits at 6.25% in a savings account for the first 5 months (above 5.90% from its previous iteration), which currently stands out among other promotions.

Comparison of bank account options for a student

As mentioned in my article on choosing a bank account as a student and beyond, I decided that my best options are regular accounts that aren’t specifically advertised as being for students. I’m already 19 years old, so I can open any bank account. I detailed my requirements and decided to put them into a table to help me decide:

Feature EQ Bank Simplii Financial Neo Financial Wealthsimple Tangerine Bank
Minimum age Province’s age of majority (18 or 19) None 14 for Quebec residents and 13 for other provinces Province’s age of majority (18 or 19) 16
Unlimited transactions Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
No monthly fees Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Separate chequing and savings Yes, by opening multiple accounts Yes Yes Yes, by opening multiple accounts Yes
Debit card Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Mobile banking Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Free ATM access Yes, fees are reimbursed CIBC ATMs only No Yes, fees are reimbursed Scotiabank ATMs only
Savings account interest rate 2.50%
Or 4.00% with direct deposit
0.40% 4.00% 3.50%
Or 4.00% with direct deposit
0.45%
Intro savings account interest rate No 6.25% for 5 months No No 6.00% for 5 months
Cheque writing No Yes No Yes Yes
Branch access No No No No No
Debit card rewards 0.5% cash back None Variable; no base rate 1% cash back None
Referral bonus $20 $50 $10 $25 $50
Sign-up bonus No $400 with 3 months of direct deposit No $100 with first direct deposit $250 with 2 months of direct deposit